Xariel avatar

RISINGSHADOW BOOKSHELF

Xariel

Journeyman· Level 45

THE READER’S VOICE

Book Reviews

Xariel’s own thoughts on books they have read. These are reader-written book reviews, separate from Risingshadow’s editorial reviews.

17 book reviews
Sort book reviewsSort: Date written · Newest first
Fallen

BOOK REVIEW

Fallen

Lauren Kate

8/10Written May 11, 2010Edited May 5, 2011
Show review marked as a spoiler

Somehow it feels that there is way too many new books using the same ideas. This book has huge similarities to two books, first and the more famous one is Twilight, and there is Alyson Noel's Evermore and its sequels. It's very noticeable when you read all of these three books, especially when you read the sequels for each one, too. Immortal guy, non-immortal girlfriend, hard time believing that their love can really work, then there is an other guy that the girl feels very strongly about, we get to know that the guy is something else than he looks like - Angel, Vampire, Immortal - it varies so no one can really blame anyone for plagiarizing, but come on, something new for once?

Fallen has its own good places, at some places the book is actually interesting and I like the characters. But then there is these moments when I start thinking "Wait a moment, didn't I just read this last week?". If you haven't read Evermore, you might not notice these similarities. But the more you read, the more disturbing it grows.

Daniel is a basic male character in this type of books, he has his secrets and he disappears suddenly and acts weird and has supernatural abilities... (Is that what girls really want, by the way?) He is handsome and tall and slim and Luce has a weirdly drawn to him from the first moment, not knowing why... Somehow by now so basic that I was actually surprised that I gave this book four stars. Well, I'm not rating the psychological side of the book or the depth of the characters as much as the basic entertainment I got.

Necropolis

BOOK REVIEW

Necropolis

Anthony Horowitz

8/10Written Sep 6, 2009

This book surprises. Somehow Mr. Horowitz has turned an ordinary fantasy story to something more. It makes you want more, and keeps you interested until the last page.

Scarlett's story is a bit scary and exciting at the same time. Raven's gate was very good, Evil Star wasn't as good as it, Nightrise could have been better, but this one was great work.

Very nice book, easy to read, makes you smile and send shivers down your spine. Can you ask much more? ^^

Dark Lover

BOOK REVIEW

Dark Lover

J. R. Ward

8/10Written Aug 5, 2009Edited Aug 5, 2009

This review is counterbalance for Seregil of Rhiminee's review.

It's not just about how the writer writes, or how beautifully the writer has made the characters or how "good quality" the book has.

It's about what you're looking for.

I can believe that some people don't like Dark Lover and it's sequels. But I'm sure that there are many people who like. If you have read hundreds of books and while reading you look specifically for quality, skillfully made characters and extraordinary storyboard, you probably don't think this book is very good. Or you think (like he does) that this is "definitely the worst book he've read this year".

When I read, I want to enjoy. Sometimes it's very nice to have those complicated storylines and intense characters hanging around, but sometimes you want something more... light? Easy? Entertaining? All of those.

And the characters are enough good to be entertaining. I'm not looking for philosophising or the ultimate questions. Dark Lover is not for young (adults) like Twilight-saga is. This is more for adults, and much more... rough.

I could write reveral lines of text more about this, but I won't do so. I think my opinion is clear enough by this. I simply say that If you are looking something like this, read this. If you [b]know[/b] that you won't like it, that you don't like books like that, don't read. It's useless. If you do like romantic books, I think you'll like this.

But I like books like this, and I like this. And that's enough for me. This is not c*ap. ;)

Breaking Dawn

BOOK REVIEW

Breaking Dawn

Stephenie Meyer

10/10Written May 25, 2009

Actually, I like this book more than other three books. The style of writing changed and that was odd. But the change was not bad - I prefer this new writing style to the older one.

I liked the ending, happily ever after was the thing I expected and got. There was still few things I didn't like, Jacob's love with you-know-who for example. But I liked so many things that I have to be "young&stupid teenage twilight fangirl" and give five stars. :p I liked it. Really.

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

BOOK REVIEW

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

J. K. Rowling

8/10Written Oct 7, 2008Edited Oct 16, 2010
Show review marked as a spoiler

The Saga of Harry Potter started in Philosopher's/Sorcerer's stone. This is the First book. Without this book, and people who read and bought this, we wouldn't have other Potters to read. It's not a bad achievement. ;)

So, I like this book. It's not my favourite one, but it's a very good book and a lot better than Harry Potter 2 or 3 or 4. Number 5 (Order of phoenix) is just like this (good), and the others too. :)

And what's the Thing in these books? Why so many people are crazy about these? I have no simple answer, but I have two little things why I like Potters so much.

The World is the thing number one. Hogwarts, Quidditch, Diagon Alley... It's so big, detailed... and reader knows a lot of things about J.K. Rowling's world without reading about these things. I mean, that thigs somehow come to your mind along the way, and that's how the world starts to live. More important is what author doesn't tell and you still know/guess them than what she tells and you know that way. That's because the most important information is hidden between the lines, instead of author saying it straight.

The Thing number two is characters. Maybe a boy like Potter isn't very unique character in fantasy, but in the books are also many minor characters who are captivating and beautifully made. For example Luna Lovegood.

Philosopher's stone starts with prologue. There are archenemy who kills little boy's parents and tries to kill the Boy also but fails. The enemy dies for a while, and the boy who stayed alive gets a lightning-blot-shaped scar in his forehead. That's the beginning.

Book tells the story of Harry Potter's first year in witches' and wizards' school. He meets new friends and other caharacters, good and evil ones... and so the story goes on.

This book will do nicely for teens and children, and I'm sure that some adults can enjoy it like their children do. :) Maybe not everyone, but some.