To Win a Dark Heart · #5

Falling For the Pirate

A Little Mermaid and Peter Pan retelling with a twist

Nicki Chapelway

9.0 / 10
2 expectations

A siren with no song
A lost boy who accidentally grew up
It was supposed to be the perfect story… not her reality.

Vera is a screenwriter at the end of her rope. She has always wanted to write a story that will bring a villainous twist to two of her favorite fairytales, but if her producer asks her to make one more edit to the script, she might just lose it.

However, when she wakes up in the world of her script, she begins to think she has already lost it. Forced into the role of her main character, a vengeful siren by the name of Moira, Vera finds herself having to live through the story of the Little Mermaid… but as the villain of the tale.

Struggling with how to get by with fins is bad enough, being doomed to get her heart broken in a love triangle of her own making is worse. But none of that compares to the fact that by some twist of fate, it seems her producer James is also in this story. And he is filling in the role of the notorious Captain Hook. James blames Vera for the fact that he is currently missing a hand and being hunted by a monstrous crocodile. He is also not too happy that his nemesis is a childlike force that is creepy beyond all reason.

Now Vera finds herself having to get herself and her producer back home safely as she struggles to survive her own story and not fall in love with either her producer or the guy she made up. But as the plot progresses, she starts to wonder if she should have been kinder to her own characters.

And maybe she should have written a happy ending after all.

Falling for the Pirate is a retelling that combines elements of The Little Mermaid and Peter Pan. With a unique portal fantasy twist this villainous tale tells the love story between Captain Hook and the Sea Witch. Full of pirates, sirens, stressed screenwriters, and sea monsters this swashbuckling romantasy is the fifth book in the To Win a Dark Heart series which retells fairytales as old as time, but this time it’s the villain’s turn to get a happy ending.

Published
February 13, 2026
Where to find this book
External links open a book search at the selected retailer. Availability may vary.
Discussions (2)

ARC Listings Available for To Win a Dark Heart Fairy Tale Series

Chelsea K739 books · 233 posts

To Win a Dark Heart is a 12 book, multi-author series with stories that mash up two fairy tales and match up their villains.

Advanced Reader Copies (ARC's) are currently available at both Booksprout and BookSirens for multiple books in this series those who are interested. 

Falling for the Mad King: A Fairy Tale Villain Mash-Up
Publication Date: Feb 20, 2026
Page Length: 202 pages
 
Booksprout ARC Link
Review by Feb 21, 2026
Review on at least 1:


  • Amazon

  • Goodreads

  • Bookbub

BookSirens ARC Link
Number of days to read: 54

Falling for the Doomed Bride: Bluebeard's Tale
Publication Date: January 23, 2026
Page Length: ?

 
Booksprout ARC Link
Review by Jan 23, 2026

Review on at least 1:


  • Amazon

  • Goodreads

  • Bookbub

Falling for the Sorcerer: A Villainous Rapunzel and Swan Lake Second Chance Romance
Publication Date: February 27, 2026
Page Length: 298 pages

BookSirens ARC Link
Number of days to read: 61

Happy reading to anyone who decides to read this series.
 
My personal recommendation (particularly if you enjoy the book a lot) is to place your review in as many places as you can and to send the author a message letting them know were you posted (including here) to let them know how much you appreciate their generosity in providing you with the opportunity to read an early copy of their book.

Edited Jan 18, 2026 02:03
Chelsea K739 books · 233 posts

Falling for the Sorcerer: A Villainous Rapunzel and Swan Lake Second Chance Romance
Publication Date: February 27, 2026
Page Length: 298 pages

Booksprout ARC Link
Review by Mar 31, 2026
Review on at least 1:


  • Amazon

  • Goodreads

  • Bookbub

  • Barnes & Noble

Falling for the Pied Piper: To Win a Dark Heart
Booksprout ARC LinkReview by Mar 21, 2026

Review on at least 1:


  • Amazon

  • Goodreads

Have something to add? You can reply as a guest, no account needed.